News

Threshing Day Summary & Theories: All 13 Stories Explained

October 1, 2026

Threshing Day Recap

Threshing Day is a collection of thirteen Empyrean stories about how familiar riders bonded their dragons. It revisits events before and during Fourth Wing and Iron Flame, rather than continuing the story after Onyx Storm. The new perspectives reveal hidden family connections, explain several dragon choices and raise questions about the records kept at Basgiath.

This Threshing Day summary and theories guide covers all thirteen stories, the main revelations and their possible implications for the next books. Use the contents below to jump to a rider or the theory section. For the rules of the event itself, see our guide to Threshing and dragon bonding.

Threshing Day at a Glance

Threshing Day is a collection of thirteen stories set in the Empyrean series, rather than Fourth Wing Book 4. The collection returns to the day dragons choose their riders and was released on September 29, 2026. For the latest on the next main-series novel, see our Fourth Wing Book 4 updates.

The collection adds new details about the riders’ families, relationships and dragon bonds. Among the biggest revelations are Sgaeyl’s connection to Maxrim Riorson, Glane’s history with Imogen’s grandmother, and Thoirt’s relationship to Deigh.

The Biggest Threshing Day Revelations

  • Glane’s history contradicts her official record. She remembers bonding Imogen’s grandmother, despite being listed as nineteen with no previous riders.
  • Xaden and Sgaeyl have different versions of his family tree. She identifies Maxrim Riorson as his grandfather; he knows him as his great-uncle.
  • Some dragons have chosen before the field encounter. Cuir has waited specifically for Bodhi, while other stories describe a pull beginning at Presentation.
  • The Mairi siblings bond sibling dragons. Thoirt is Deigh’s sister, and she identifies a gift Sloane inherited from their mother.
  • The chapters add motives to familiar decisions. Dain faces pressure from his father, Sawyer learns why his first year ended without a bond, and Aaric rejects service to the monarchy.

These revelations do not all have the same status. A dragon’s stated family connection is part of the story; a prediction about a second signet or a future betrayal is an interpretation. Jump to the theories and open questions for that distinction.

Every Threshing Day Story Explained

1. Brennan and Marbh

Brennan and Marbh — fan illustration
Brennan and Marbh

Brennan enters Threshing determined to prove himself beyond the Sorrengail name. Before he heads into the forest, his father visits, reassures him that he is proud of his choices and gives him his good-luck bracelet.

Going alone, Brennan climbs a tree and encounters Marbh, an orange daggertail—exactly the kind of unpredictable dragon he hoped to avoid. Marbh challenges him to reach his back without touching the ground. Brennan jumps from a branch onto the dragon’s head, then scrambles into position as Marbh takes flight.

Marbh’s challenge tests Brennan’s courage and ability to adapt, establishing the demanding dynamic between them from their first flight.

2. Mira and Teine

Mira and Teine — fan illustration
Mira and Teine

Mira enters Threshing determined to find Teine, the green clubtail she felt drawn to during Presentation. After separating from her squadmate Cowan, she follows her instincts straight to him.

Teine tests her composure by felling a tree beside her, then piercing her thigh with a talon. Despite the pain, Mira stands her ground. When he questions where her loyalties lie within the Sorrengail family, she insists that she belongs to herself and intends to use her power to protect those she loves.

Teine chooses Mira as his first rider. She completes their first flight despite her injury, but her happiness is tinged with disappointment when she discovers her mother has not come to watch. Teine promptly makes it clear that his approval is the only validation she should seek now.

3. Xaden and Sgaeyl

Xaden and Sgaeyl — fan illustration
Xaden and Sgaeyl

Xaden enters Threshing determined to keep all ten marked cadets alive. But when Prince Alic Tauri and two other cadets take Garrick hostage, Xaden is forced into a deadly confrontation. Under Sgaeyl’s watchful gaze, he kills Alic to protect his friend. Sgaeyl then incinerates the bodies, removing the evidence.

Once they are alone, Sgaeyl demands complete honesty. Xaden admits that he refuses to remain helpless after witnessing his father’s execution and intends to give the marked ones the power to survive.

Sgaeyl drops a surprising family revelation: she identifies her former rider, Maxrim Riorson, as Xaden’s grandfather. Xaden, however, knows him as his great-uncle. He lets it slide for now, leaving a discrepancy in the Riorson family tree. She has already seen his memories, flaws and potential, and chooses him with full knowledge of his secrets—and Xaden immediately tests their new partnership by admitting that he would like to burn Basgiath to the ground.

4. Garrick and Chradh

Garrick and Chradh — fan illustration
Garrick and Chradh

Garrick leaves Xaden with Sgaeyl reluctantly—protecting his best friend is practically second nature. His father once served beside Fen Riorson, and Garrick carries that loyalty into the next generation. The chapter also reveals that he has loved Imogen since she punched him in the face when they were nine, and that seeing her again is one of the things keeping him going.

The dragon calling him is Chradh, a brown scorpiontail who has never bonded before. But something doesn’t quite add up: he is only twenty-seven, yet his voice sounds much older, and he speaks with a confidence Garrick wasn’t expecting. Chradh chooses him for his history of acting for others—and hints that he knows exactly what power Garrick needs.

5. Dain and Cath

Dain and Cath — fan illustration
Dain and Cath

Dain enters Threshing desperate to make his father proud, but their conversation beforehand reveals just how much pressure he is under. His father tells him the marked ones were never supposed to survive and asks him to watch for opportunities to report them. He even uses Dain’s fear for Violet’s safety to persuade him.

In the forest, Dain saves fellow cadet Joelle from a fall before finding himself caught between a green dragon—the choice his father has arranged—and Cath, a red swordtail. For once, Dain follows what feels right rather than what his father wants, jumping onto Cath’s back.

Cath demands that their bond come before the Codex, orders and even Dain’s father. Dain agrees, ending the chapter with something he has never felt before: a connection to someone who already knows everything about him, without the constant fear of disappointing them.

6. Bodhi and Cuir

Bodhi and Cuir — fan illustration
Bodhi and Cuir

Bodhi enters Threshing tired of being seen as Xaden’s cousin—or his replacement. He loves him like a brother, but wants to be chosen for himself. Their conversation also reveals what Bodhi’s mother asked of him before her death: stay close to Xaden, let him protect him, and keep him in balance.

Xaden tells him that Cuir is waiting, but Bodhi resents having another decision made for him. When he spots a blue clubtail instead, he runs straight toward it—even as Xaden shouts for him to stop. Cuir, a green swordtail, snatches him out of the path of its fire, then makes it clear that Bodhi can still refuse their bond. He understands how much choice has been taken from him, though he won’t tolerate another reckless attempt to get himself killed.

Cuir chooses Bodhi because he wants power to stop people being hurt, rather than simply to win. He has waited until this year specifically for him. For someone used to watching Xaden be everyone’s first choice, that matters—and Bodhi promises to choose Cuir over everyone else.

7. Imogen and Glane

Imogen and Glane — fan illustration
Imogen and Glane

Imogen enters Threshing furious at Navarre and grieving her mother and sister, Katrina. Garrick catches up with her, and their teasing turns into jealousy and very obvious attraction. She pushes him away because everyone she loves dies, but he refuses to leave her to face the day alone.

The chapter also develops her friendship with Quinn. Despite Imogen’s attempts to keep people at a distance, Quinn has become her best friend. When Glane threatens Quinn, Imogen immediately steps in to protect her.

The biggest reveal is that Glane previously bonded Imogen’s grandmother and remembers meeting Imogen as a child. Official records, however, list the orange daggertail as only nineteen with no previous riders. They agree to keep each other’s secrets, and Imogen leaves Threshing with her grandmother’s dragon.

8. Rhiannon and Feirge

Rhiannon and Feirge — fan illustration
Rhiannon and Feirge

Rhiannon is thrilled about Threshing, even as her friends struggle with nerves. But when she finds Visia badly burned by an orange dragon, bonding takes second place. She refuses to leave another cadet defenseless—even when the second-years observing tell her to move on.

Feirge, a green daggertail, steps in and drives the orange away. She has been calling Rhiannon since Presentation, where her confidence already caught the dragon’s attention. Feirge sees a future leader in her, and Rhiannon demonstrates why: before leaving, she makes sure Visia will have a place in their squad if she survives.

Getting onto Feirge’s back takes some improvisation. Rhiannon borrows an idea from Violet’s approach to the Gauntlet, using gaps between the scales to pull herself up. Once they are airborne, she wishes her twin sister, Raegan, could experience it with her.

9. Sawyer and Sliseag

Sawyer and Sliseag — fan illustration
Sawyer and Sliseag

Sawyer enters his second Threshing determined that he will leave as a rider or die trying. Repeating the year has left him ashamed and furious: he followed every rule, performed well and still watched other cadets bond while he ended up in the infirmary. He has tried to keep his new friends at a distance, but admits that Ridoc might be his favorite person in their year.

When Sliseag, a red swordtail, chooses him, Sawyer assumes the dragon has made a mistake. Their first conversation quickly becomes an argument—and Sliseag likes it. Sawyer’s carefully hidden anger matches his own, and he values his stubbornness and determination to keep going. He demands honesty within their bond, including the feelings Sawyer has spent a year trying to hide.

The reassurance Sawyer needs finally comes: he was never unworthy; Sliseag simply wasn’t ready yet. By the time Sawyer climbs onto his back, he admits he would have repeated another year if he had known this dragon would be waiting.

10. Ridoc and Aotrom

Ridoc and Aotrom — fan illustration
Ridoc and Aotrom

Ridoc starts Threshing terrified, nauseous and trying to convince himself that any dragon would be lucky to have him. Then Aotrom, a twenty-one-year-old brown swordtail, splashes him with water. Ridoc immediately objects: he needs a responsible dragon to keep him in check, not someone just as impulsive as he is.

Aotrom has heard that argument from his own elders. He wants a rider who matches his energy and mischief, and recognizes that Ridoc also knows what it means to be underestimated. The chapter reveals that Ridoc grew up using humor to ease the tension between his arguing parents. With Aotrom, though, he quickly discovers what it’s like to be on the receiving end.

To earn his seat, Ridoc has to catch a dragon who can climb trees—and keeps swinging his swordtail into his path. He finally uses his belt, nearby branches and sheer determination to reach Aotrom’s back. Their first flight begins with Ridoc pointing out the tree sap he has left across the dragon’s scales. Aotrom refuses to call them even, but does declare them equals.

11. Liam and Deigh

Liam and Deigh — fan illustration
Liam and Deigh

Liam spends Threshing carving a wooden dragon with his father’s penknife, certain that Deigh will find him. Xaden joins him, and their conversation shows the closeness of their relationship: Liam teases him about Violet, while Xaden reminds him that he’ll need to help protect the marked ones after he graduates.

The chapter also reveals that Liam has been writing letters to Sloane and saving them for her arrival at Basgiath. They haven’t been able to communicate since he crossed the parapet, and he wants her to know she hasn’t been forgotten.

When Deigh appears, he reveals that dragons in his line have previously bonded riders in Liam’s family. He knows Liam’s mother’s name and title, Rune Master Colonel Mairi, and intends to fight the evil beyond Navarre’s borders with him. For Liam, the bond means he can finally do something beyond surviving and protecting Xaden. The chapter ends with him becoming Deigh’s rider—and describing it as the last chapter of his life.

12. Sloane and Thoirt

Sloane and Thoirt — fan illustration
Sloane and Thoirt

Sloane enters Threshing with no intention of bonding. Grieving Liam and furious at Basgiath, she wants nothing to do with becoming another weapon for Navarre. Imogen finds her first, bringing the wooden Deigh figurine Liam was carrying when he died. She also tells Sloane that a red daggertail named Thoirt is looking for her.

When Sloane deliberately walks toward an orange dragon, Dain breaks the rules to pull her out of its path. She lashes out at him for his part in Liam’s death, but finally admits how badly she is hurting. He stays until Thoirt arrives.

The dragon reveals that she is Deigh’s sister. Rather than demanding that Sloane fight, she offers her time to grieve and the choice she has been denied. Thoirt also confirms that Sloane inherited their mother’s gift, while Liam did not, and promises Sloane that she will never be alone again. Sloane chooses her—and asks to fly back to her friends.

13. Aaric and Molvic

Aaric and Molvic — fan illustration
Aaric and Molvic

Aaric spends Threshing looking for Molvic, the blue clubtail he already feels drawn to. He’s prepared to repeat the year rather than settle for another dragon. Raised largely by his mother, he learned to value restraint over the cruelty he saw in Alic—which helps explain why he wants a different path from the rest of his family.

Molvic knows exactly who he is—and has previously considered bonding someone in his bloodline, only to regret it. He challenges Aaric to prove that he is different from his family. Aaric insists he will earn his power and fight the war beyond the wards, even if it costs him his life.

Then he makes his intentions unmistakable: he will fly as Aaric Graycastle, not as a prince serving the monarchy. He condemns his family’s complicity and tells Molvic he intends to tear the kingdom apart. Molvic accepts his terms—and addresses him by his chosen name.

Threshing Day Theories and Easter Eggs

The stories reveal why these riders and dragons chose one another. They also leave open questions about inherited gifts, unreliable records and the limits of dragon knowledge. The following sections distinguish what the collection reveals from what those details might foreshadow.

Explore the theories: Future signets · Imogen’s possible second signet · Dragon records · The professors · Early claiming · Blood and bonding · Xaden’s family · Dragon family lines · Bodhi and venin power · Imogen and Garrick · Asher and the bracelet · Cowan and Violet’s armor · Sloane’s gift

Fourth Wing Threshing Day
Threshing Day

How the Riders’ Thoughts Foreshadow Their Future Signets

Knowing the abilities these riders later develop changes how their early thoughts read. Mira’s focus on protecting her family, Imogen’s wish to erase an awkward moment and Garrick’s longing to close the distance between himself and Imogen all echo their future powers.

Swipe sideways to see the full table →

RiderWish, Need or ThoughtFuture Signet
BrennanWants to help and heal Violet.Mending
MiraWants the power to protect her family.Extending wards
XadenWatches for threats in the shadows and wants to understand others’ intentions.Shadow wielding and intention reading
GarrickLongs to close the distance between himself and Imogen.Distance wielding
BodhiCarries his mother’s instruction to keep Xaden in balance.Countering signets
ImogenWishes she could remove a vulnerable moment from Garrick’s memory.Memory erasure
SawyerImagines reshaping his emotions through metalworking imagery.Metallurgy
LiamWishes he could see Sloane despite the distance between them.Farsight
AaricWants control over his future.Precognition
RidocSuggests snow could help remove the tree sap from Aotrom.Ice wielding

These are possible connections between the riders’ thoughts and their future signets. Some reflect deeper needs; others work as playful Easter eggs.

The parallels range from fundamental needs to lighter Easter eggs. Ridoc proposing snow as a solution to Aotrom’s tree sap is a playful example. These details can be read as foreshadowing without assuming that every passing wish determines an ability—or that a dragon can predict the exact signet before bonding.

Does Glane’s Previous Bond Mean Imogen Has a Second Signet?

The reveal: Glane previously bonded Imogen’s grandmother and remembers Imogen as a child. This places their bond alongside Xaden and Sgaeyl’s: the same dragon chooses a previous rider’s direct descendant.

The main series associates such bonds with a second signet or madness, making another ability a plausible question for Imogen. The collection does not name or demonstrate that ability, however. Her agreement with Glane to keep secrets adds intrigue, but it does not establish which secrets she might later conceal.

Why Do the Dragon Records Contradict Glane’s History?

Glane’s recorded age of nineteen and the claim that she has never bonded are incompatible with her account of Imogen’s grandmother. This is a discrepancy in the information available to the cadets, rather than merely an impression that a dragon seems older than expected.

Several explanations remain possible: inaccurate identification, incomplete records or deliberate concealment of earlier bonds. The text does not identify who is responsible. Chradh’s older-sounding voice becomes more interesting in that context, but a voice alone cannot prove a false age or a previous rider.

Who Do the Dragonkind Professors Ultimately Answer To?

The professors teach at Basgiath, prepare cadets for Threshing and pass on information about dragons. Their responsibilities to the Empyrean raise a separate question about what happens if dragon interests and Navarre’s interests diverge.

Glane’s record makes the limits of that information particularly relevant. Do the professors know the histories are incomplete, or are the dragons withholding information from them as well? Nothing in the discrepancy alone establishes that Kaori knowingly deceives his students. The unresolved issue is how much the teachers know and what they are permitted to share.

Was Imogen Chosen Before Threshing Began?

Glane has already placed a claiming mark on Imogen during Presentation. Cuir has waited specifically for Bodhi, while Feirge has been calling Rhiannon since Presentation. The stories therefore show that some dragons make their selection before the encounter in the valley.

An early claim is not necessarily a completed bond. It suggests that Threshing can be the culmination of an existing choice rather than a first meeting. Chradh’s interest in what Garrick needs raises a related question: can dragons anticipate an ability, or are they simply assessing a candidate’s character and motivations?

Does Blood Play a Role in Dragon Bonding?

Teine deliberately pierces Mira’s thigh. Other riders bleed after fights or difficult climbs, and Ridoc notices an injured knee that he attributes to landing on a twig. The repeated attention to these injuries invites the theory that blood might contribute to bonding or help dragons identify something about a candidate.

A related possibility connects the injuries with the discussion of venin and bleeding in Onyx Storm: could a dragon be testing a prospective rider? Neither explanation is established. Threshing is dangerous enough to account for accidental injuries, and Ridoc’s scrape need not have a hidden cause. The pattern is worth examining without turning every wound into evidence of a ritual.

What Is Missing from Xaden’s Family History?

Sgaeyl identifies Maxrim Riorson as Xaden’s grandfather, but Xaden knows him as his great-uncle. The important addition is not that Sgaeyl bonded an ancestor—the main series already establishes that connection—but that Xaden did not understand it in the same way at his Threshing.

That leaves questions about who knew the relationship, how the alternative family history reached Xaden and when he learned the truth. A grandfather and a great-uncle carry different implications for direct descent. The story shows Sgaeyl choosing him with knowledge he does not yet share; it does not identify who concealed or misunderstood that history.

Why Do Dragons Return to the Same Human Families?

The family connections are broader than Xaden and Imogen. Deigh explains that dragons in his line have bonded riders in Liam’s family before. Sloane then bonds Thoirt, Deigh’s sister. These connections suggest a history between the dragon and human families beyond the two siblings.

The distinction matters: related dragons choosing related humans is not the same as one dragon bonding a direct descendant of its former rider. Deigh and Thoirt’s sibling relationship does not by itself establish a second signet for either Mairi. Similarly, Molvic’s earlier interest in Aaric’s bloodline does not establish a completed previous bond. Alic is a possible connection, not a confirmed former rider or ancestor.

Could Bodhi’s Promise Foreshadow a Turn Toward Venin Power?

Bodhi’s thought that he will never be powerless again initially marks a moment of hope: Cuir has chosen him for himself. Cuir reinforces the vow, while Bodhi’s mother’s instruction to keep Xaden in balance links his new power to a deeply personal responsibility.

The tension emerges when this is read alongside Onyx Storm. Against Theophanie, Bodhi believes his countering signet can provide balance, but Violet concludes that it works on their magic rather than venin magic. His power cannot guarantee that he can protect everyone.

The venin theory asks what he might do if protecting Xaden required power beyond that limit. Would he accept helplessness or seek another source? Cuir’s distinction between death and demise adds another possible warning. These details provide a basis for discussing temptation or downfall, not confirmation that Bodhi turns.

Has Imogen Erased Memories of Her Relationship with Garrick?

Garrick’s feelings date back to childhood, while Imogen’s fear of losing someone she loves complicates their attraction. Her wish to remove a vulnerable moment from his memory echoes the ability she later develops.

One interpretation is straightforward foreshadowing. Another is that later gaps or uncertainty in their relationship might involve memories she has actually removed. The collection supplies the wish, not evidence that she has acted on it. Any theory about forgotten encounters needs to keep that distinction intact.

Asher Sorrengail’s Bracelet, Research and Death

Asher’s visit to Brennan shows an affectionate father who makes time for his son and gives him a good-luck bracelet. His presence on the Threshing field, his research and the suggestion that rule-breaking has affected his rank also leave questions about his work and priorities.

The gift invites comparison with the bracelet Mira wears in Onyx Storm, which Violet finds familiar and associates with the smell of parchment. A family connection is possible, but the two objects should not be treated as the same bracelet without further evidence. Nor does their significance establish a magical purpose.

Asher’s fear of what losing Brennan would do to the family also reads as foreshadowing beside the account of his own death after Brennan’s supposed death. Whether grief is the entire explanation remains a question. His research and gifts create lines of inquiry, rather than proof of a particular secret or cause of death.

Could Cowan Be the Friend Who Helped Make Violet’s Armor?

Cowan’s joke about wanting to grow taller recalls the friend Mira mentions in Fourth Wing who can change the size of objects and helps with Violet’s protective armor. His remark could foreshadow that ability and identify him as the unnamed friend.

This remains a possible Easter egg, not a confirmed identity. If the connection is intentional, it would link a brief moment in Mira’s Threshing story to her later efforts to protect Violet.

What Does Thoirt Mean by Sloane’s Inherited Gift?

Thoirt states that Sloane inherited a gift from her mother that Liam did not. Liam’s chapter also identifies their mother as a rune master. This leaves the nature of the inheritance open to discussion: whether it concerns siphoning, an aptitude connected with runes or a family capacity that still needs explanation.

An inherited gift and a signet manifested through a dragon bond are not automatically the same thing. Thoirt’s statement should not be used on its own to establish an additional signet or a general rule for passing powers from parent to child.

Taken together, the strongest unresolved threads concern the reliability of dragon records, the significance of family lines and how well dragons understand the people they choose. Some smaller details may remain Easter eggs; others could change how these bonds are understood in the next main-series books.

Does Threshing Day Change the Ending of Onyx Storm?

Threshing Day does not move the timeline beyond Onyx Storm or resolve its ending. Its contribution is retrospective: it changes the context around familiar riders, family histories and dragon choices. The final story follows Aaric and Molvic, whose agreement establishes Aaric’s rejection of the monarchy rather than a new post-Onyx Storm event.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens in Threshing Day?

Thirteen riders face Threshing and bond their dragons, from Brennan and Marbh to Aaric and Molvic. The stories reveal the choices, fears and family connections behind bonds already familiar from the main novels.

How many stories are in Threshing Day?

There are thirteen stories in the collection.

Is Threshing Day Fourth Wing Book 4?

No. Threshing Day is a separate collection of stories within the Empyrean series. The fourth main novel is a different book.

Which characters appear in Threshing Day?

The thirteen stories follow Brennan, Mira, Xaden, Garrick, Dain, Bodhi, Imogen, Rhiannon, Sawyer, Ridoc, Liam, Sloane and Aaric. Other familiar characters, including Violet and Quinn, appear within their stories.

When should you read Threshing Day?

For the fullest context and to avoid revealing later connections early, read Fourth Wing, Iron Flame and Onyx Storm before the collection. This article also discusses all three main novels, so its spoiler scope is wider than an individual early story.

Do you need to read Threshing Day before Fourth Wing Book 4?

No. Rebecca Yarros has confirmed that you do not need to read Threshing Day to understand Book 4. The collection adds background to familiar characters and their dragons, but it is optional reading.

No comments

Leave a Comment


A Court of Splintered Harmony Theories

A Court of Splintered Harmony Theories: Nesta, the Prison and What Comes Next

Crescent City Spicy Chapters

Crescent City Spicy Chapters: Every Steamy & Romantic Chapter