What is Nesta doing in the Prison? Where has Gwydion gone? And why does Amren seem to know exactly where to send her? Those are the questions we keep coming back to after A Court of Splintered Harmony. Add Elain’s secrets, that ribbon from Clotho and everything happening between Nesta and Cassian, and there is plenty to argue about before the next book.
Some ACOSH theories have us reopening Crescent City. Others have us defending couples we are currently furious with. Here are the ideas we find most interesting, including the ones we enjoy discussing even when we do not quite believe them.
Spoilers for ACOSH, the earlier ACOTAR books, Crescent City and Throne of Glass. For a refresher on what actually happens, start with our A Court of Splintered Harmony summary and ending explained.
A Court of Splintered Harmony Theories at a Glance
- What is Nesta doing in the Prison?
- Why did Gwydion disappear?
- Was that really Amren?
- Is Narben beneath the sea?
- Are Nesta and Rhysand carranam?
- Did Nesta create her mating bond?
- Will Nesta and Cassian stay together?
- Are Nesta and Eris mates?
- Is Elain evil?
- Clotho, Bryaxis and Nyx’s ribbon
- Why does Truth-Teller sing?
- Are Azriel and Gwyn mates?
- Is someone weakening the Night Court?
What Is Nesta Doing in the Prison?
Nesta wants answers about the Prison, Gwydion, her power and the eight-pointed star on her back. But arriving there feels like the beginning of a much bigger story. She finally takes a step toward finding those answers, and almost immediately loses the sword she brought with her.
That is a frustrating place to leave her. It is also a good reason to suspect the island has more in store for her than a conversation about its history.

Will Nesta Restore the Dusk Court?
We can see why this theory has caught on. Nesta is searching for a purpose of her own, and the Prison sits at the heart of a history that Bryce’s arrival has brought back into the story. Helping restore what was lost would give Nesta something substantial to build beyond the life the Night Court has planned for her.
The part we are less sure about is the automatic promotion to High Lady. Nesta could help restore the territory without ruling it. Bryce’s family history matters here, too. We want Nesta to have a future she chooses; a crown is only one possible version of that future.
Did Nesta Reach Another Realm Through the Prison?
There is also the possibility that Nesta has reached somewhere other than the part of the Prison she knows. An ancient island with hidden passages and old magic leaves plenty of room for surprises, including a connection to another realm.
We would need a clearer sign before calling it world-walking. For now, a part of the island no one has explained to her seems just as plausible. Either way, she may have arrived with the wrong idea of what she was walking into.
Why Did Gwydion Disappear? Could Nesta Face a Starsword Trial?
Gwydion’s disappearance could be the start of a trial like the one Ruhn faced on Avallen. This is the Crescent City parallel that makes the ending especially interesting to us. Bryce handed Nesta the sword, but perhaps Nesta still has something to discover before she can truly claim it for herself.
How Did Ruhn Get the Starsword on Avallen?
Ruhn obtained the Starsword during his Ordeal on Avallen, in the Cave of Princes. Flynn and Declan went through that ordeal with him. In House of Sky and Breath, Ruhn also explains that Cormac had expected to enter the caves and prove himself worthy of the sword. Ruhn came out with it instead.
So there is already a history of this particular weapon being won through a dangerous journey. Calling Nesta’s possible challenge an Ordeal is a comparison, though: we do not yet know whether the Prison has any equivalent to that Crescent City rite.
What makes the parallel appealing is the difference between their starting points. Ruhn went into the caves without the Starsword and emerged with it. Nesta arrives carrying Gwydion and then loses it. Her task could be to find it again, with the search forcing her to confront something about the island, the weapon or herself.
We like that possibility because it gives the disappearance a purpose beyond taking away her protection. Bryce’s gift could have brought Nesta to the beginning of the journey rather than spared her the journey altogether.
Of course, someone inside the Prison could simply have taken it. An enchantment could be involved, too. We are keeping the trial theory high on our list because of Ruhn, not because the ending has already told us Nesta must prove herself worthy.
Was That Really Amren at the End of ACOSH?
Then there is the person who sent her there. Amren encourages Nesta to take Gwydion to the Prison, which leaves us wondering how much she expected to happen once Nesta arrived.
The “Miss Quinlan” wording is what sends the impersonation theory toward Aidas. Other versions suggest Apollion or some kind of outside influence. It is a detail worth noticing, especially after the crossover, but we would not identify a character from that phrase alone.
Amren having an agenda of her own is at least as interesting as someone wearing her face. If Nesta really is about to face a trial, did Amren know? And if she did, why leave Nesta to discover that part for herself?
Is Narben Beneath the Sea Near the Prison?
Before Nesta even reaches the Prison, something beneath the water catches her attention. The familiar quality of its magic has led to the suggestion that she is sensing Narben.
A missing weapon beneath the sea would fit rather neatly into a story where everyone wants access to powerful objects. It would also make the failed crossing something we need to revisit, rather than just a frightening interruption on the way to the island.
We are interested, but Nesta has not identified it. It could be another object or something alive. We would also keep it separate from Gwydion’s disappearance for now; being near the same island does not necessarily mean the two mysteries have the same answer.
Are Nesta and Rhysand Carranam?
This one is about their magic. Carranam does not mean Nesta and Rhysand are secretly mates. The theory borrows the idea of a magical partnership from Throne of Glass and asks whether something similar could explain their connection.
The sea rescue is the scene everyone comes back to. Why does Rhys reach her? What does he hear or sense? Given how difficult their relationship has been, an unexpected connection between their powers would certainly give them something new to deal with.
Rhys is also a daemati with extraordinary abilities, so we do not need carranam to explain every moment of awareness between them. We would be more persuaded by an actual exchange of power. Until then, it is an interesting possibility rather than our first explanation for the rescue.
Did Nesta Create Her Mating Bond With Cassian?
The Made-bond theory asks whether Nesta created her connection to Cassian herself. It existed before ACOSH, but their problems have given it another round of attention.
We are not convinced. A painful relationship does not mean a false bond, and Nesta’s ability to Make objects does not tell us she Made a mating bond. The suggestion that Cassian sensed something between them before her transformation is another part of their history this theory has to explain.
Will Nesta and Cassian Stay Together?
We believe Nesta and Cassian are endgame. We want the story to deal with what has gone wrong between them, rather than explain their whole relationship away. There is more on their history in our Nesta and Cassian relationship guide.
But Cassian Has to Choose Nesta
Believing they belong together does not mean being happy with everything Cassian does. He needs to choose her, and she needs to feel that choice when it costs him something—not only when everyone else approves.
When Nesta’s needs clash with Rhys’s expectations or the Inner Circle’s wishes, we want Cassian to think for himself and stand up for his partner. He can disagree with her. He can tell her she is wrong. But she should not have to wonder whether his loyalty to everyone else will always come first.
That is the relationship development we want: Cassian showing up for Nesta through his decisions, and the two of them rebuilding trust. The bond cannot do that work for him. We can be angry with him and still want them together. In fact, wanting them together is why his choices matter so much.
Are Nesta and Eris Mates?
Eris knows how to make an offer memorable. His continued interest in Nesta makes this an easy theory to enjoy, particularly when Cassian is frustrating us.
But Eris has several reasons to want that marriage. Nesta is powerful, politically valuable and someone he clearly finds interesting. Provoking Cassian may be an added benefit. A mating bond is not the only explanation for his persistence.
We still see Nessian as endgame. What Eris can do is make the contrast uncomfortable: what does he recognize in Nesta, and does Cassian make her feel equally seen? That question could matter without Eris becoming her true mate.
Is Elain Evil in A Court of Splintered Harmony?
Elain’s secrecy has produced several very different theories. In one, she knowingly helps an enemy. In another, someone is manipulating her. The most extreme version suggests the person who came out of the Cauldron was not really Elain at all.
Did Elain Literally Die in the Cauldron?
This theory takes her words about her old self dying in the Cauldron as a literal confession. Add the shadows avoiding her and questions about what Lucien’s eye might see, and the speculation quickly turns toward possession, replacement or Koschei.
It is unsettling to think about. We also find the ordinary meaning of those words convincing: her human life ended, her future was taken from her and she emerged as someone she had never chosen to become. That is a huge loss without a second person having to occupy her body.
Is Koschei Manipulating Elain?
A bargain would be a less drastic explanation than a replacement. Someone could exploit what Elain wants or what she has seen. She might even believe she is preventing something worse.
Her visions leave room for a plan the rest of the family does not understand. But secrecy alone does not make that plan malicious. We would want to know what she thinks she is doing before deciding whom she is doing it for.
Will Elain Leave the Night Court for the Spring Court?
This is the alternative we keep coming back to. Elain may need distance from her family to work out who she is. That could involve difficult choices and hurt feelings without turning her into a villain.
The description of Night Court black draining her in A Court of Silver Flames is often brought into this discussion. Alongside the gardens and spring imagery surrounding her, it makes a future connected to the Spring Court tempting to imagine.
That does not have to mean Tamlin. Elain could help restore a place, form her own alliances or find a use for her gifts beyond what her sisters expect. We would love to see her make a life that surprises them. She does not owe them permanent stillness just because change makes them uncomfortable.
Why Did Clotho Give Nyx the Ribbon—and Protect Bryaxis?
Clotho’s gift looks much harder to dismiss after the ceremony. Is the ribbon connected to stygian spidersilk? Did someone know what was about to happen with Bryaxis? And why does Clotho protect the creature afterward?
The darker theories connect those details into a planned attack. Some go further and suggest the ribbon could interfere with Nyx’s fate or age. We can follow the association with threads and life, but the ribbon’s actual purpose is still a missing piece.
Who Is Clotho Really? Could She Be a Fate?
We like this explanation more than the idea that Clotho has secretly been malicious all along. Her connection to the Mother could mean she understands something about fate that the other characters do not.
Her name makes the theory especially appealing: in Greek mythology, Clotho spins the thread of life. Put that beside a mysterious ribbon and it is hard not to wonder. Perhaps the gift has something to do with protection or destiny rather than harm.
A name and a ribbon cannot settle her identity, but they give this theory a memorable starting point. It would also allow Clotho to have kept an enormous secret without making the library’s sanctuary a lie.

Are Clotho and Bryaxis Evil?
The library matters as a refuge for women who have survived violence. That is part of why we are reluctant to assume its protector has been plotting against them. Clotho can know more than she admits and still be trying to protect someone.
With Bryaxis, we want the history we have not heard yet. A tragic past would not excuse the danger at the ceremony, but it might explain motives that currently look incomprehensible. We are much more interested in finding out what Bryaxis wants than deciding we already understand it.
Why Does Truth-Teller Sing? The ACOSH Music Theory
The music references are some of our favorite details to put side by side. They turn up in relationships, around the shadows and in the language used for powerful weapons. Once you start noticing them, the question becomes whether they are all doing the same kind of work.

Nesta and Cassian: Music Between Their Souls
This description from Nesta’s perspective is especially hard to ignore:
“For it was music between their souls. Always had been. And his voice was her favorite melody.”
The “always had been” is what stays with us. Nesta describes something familiar and deeply rooted between them, which is another reason we struggle with the idea that their entire connection is a fabrication.
And then there is “melody.” Beside the other musical references, that choice of word makes us wonder how closely souls and magic are connected. It is a romantic passage first, but it may belong to a pattern that reaches beyond Nessian.
Why Does Erebos Mention Truth-Teller’s Song Now?
Erebos asks Azriel about the blade that sings, then describes its sound in terms of grief and pain before calling it a “Song of Songs.” Meanwhile, Azriel’s shadows crowd into the corners, repulsed by him. This is a very strange conversation to leave unanswered.
The detail we find most interesting comes afterward. Erebos has seen Truth-Teller many times over the centuries. He has never mentioned singing before. Azriel himself wonders whether Bryce has changed something.
So why now? Has the blade changed since the crossover? Can Erebos hear something he could not hear before? Or has he known all along and only now decided to say it? Azriel’s question puts Bryce in the conversation, but it does not tell us which explanation is right.
There is a Crescent City connection worth remembering here, too: the Starsword also responds to Bryce with sound in House of Sky and Breath. That makes Erebos’s description feel less isolated. We now have musical language around both blades, as well as around Nesta and Cassian’s souls.
Our suspicion is that music may be a way magic recognizes a person or another source of power. If so, hearing a weapon’s song could tell a character something the wielder does not yet understand. We want to know what Erebos heard—and whether Azriel could learn to hear it himself.
Why Do Azriel’s Shadows React Differently to Elain and Gwyn?
Naturally, the shadows bring us back to the ships. Their reactions around Gwyn and Elain invite different readings, especially when Gwyn’s singing enters the discussion. We would leave room for a romantic connection and a magical explanation to overlap.
But we are not ready to make the shadows responsible for announcing everyone’s endgame. Their behavior is interesting precisely because we do not fully understand it yet.
Are Azriel and Gwyn Mates?
We do not think the absence of a recognized bond rules them out. A relationship can develop before the characters understand what it means, and a slower story would make sense for two people carrying so much hurt.
There is also something appealing about Azriel looking for a pattern in the Archeron sisters while missing a connection growing somewhere else. That would be a satisfying surprise if the story develops it.
Still, we would not treat trauma as a proven reason a bond has stayed hidden. That is one proposed explanation. For now, Gwynriel remains a possibility we are interested in, alongside the other unresolved relationships.
Is Someone Deliberately Weakening the Night Court?
Put the strained relationships, damaged alliances and uncertainty around the weapons together, and it is easy to see why people suspect a coordinated attack. An enemy would have a much easier time with a court whose members no longer trust one another.

Koschei benefiting from the fractures would make sense. The harder question is whether he caused them. Some of these problems have long histories, and the characters are perfectly capable of hurting each other without magical interference.
We could see an enemy exploiting those weaknesses, perhaps nudging an existing conflict at the right moment. We would find that more convincing than a reveal that excuses every bad decision as someone else’s spell.
What Could Happen After A Court of Splintered Harmony?
The Starsword trial is now one of our favorites. Ruhn gives us a reason to take it seriously, and Nesta searching the Prison for Gwydion could bring several of the ending’s mysteries together. Amren’s role in sending her there makes it even more interesting.
The music references are close behind. Erebos choosing this moment to mention Truth-Teller’s song feels worth remembering, especially when the other blade has its own history of singing.
As for the relationships, we are still rooting for Nesta and Cassian. We want Cassian to earn the reconciliation we hope they get, Elain to have room to surprise us and Clotho to have secrets that do not undo what the library means.
Which theory are you backing? Tell us what you think Nesta will find in the Prison—and whether you think Gwydion has been stolen or is waiting for her to find it.



No comments